penny-pinching vs redemptive

penny-pinching

adj
  • reluctant to spend money; close-fisted 

noun
  • Instance of extreme economy. 

  • reluctance to spend money; thrift or parsimony 

redemptive

adj
  • Causing, or relating to, redemption or saving; redeeming. 

How often have the words penny-pinching and redemptive occurred in a corpus of books? (source: Google Ngram Viewer )