paranormal vs thaumaturgical

paranormal

adj
  • That (ostensibly) cannot be explained by what scientists know; supernatural; especially of or pertaining to ghosts, spirits, and hypothesized abilities like telepathy. 

noun
  • A person to whom paranormal powers are attributed. 

thaumaturgical

adj
  • Relating to thaumaturgy; magical. 

How often have the words paranormal and thaumaturgical occurred in a corpus of books? (source: Google Ngram Viewer )